Mentorship That Pays: BBBS Harvard/Treasury Study Shows 15% Income Boost With 400% ROI

Big Brothers Big Sisters of America
Original Source Date: January 27, 2025


Impact Highlights


ActivitiesOutcomesIndicators

,

Annual ROIGeographyDemographics
80.0%

Article Details


Earlier this year, Big Brothers Big Sisters of America (BBBSA) released a landmark longitudinal study (with Harvard and the U.S. Treasury) revealing that one-to-one youth mentorship substantially improves long-term economic and social outcomes. Tracking participants from adolescence into young adulthood, the study shows a 15%–20% earnings gain, increased college attendance, reduced behavior issues, and improved social wellbeing.

Key Outcomes & Social Impact

    • Earnings increase: 15% more income at ages 20–25—significant for families overcoming poverty.

    • Higher education: 20% greater likelihood of college enrollment vs. non-mentored peers.

    • Better behavior: Lower absenteeism and fewer suspensions within 18 months.

    • Social health: Stronger support networks and reduced reliance on social services.

Annual ROI—Precise & Fast

    • Cost per youth: $2,500 annually (programmatic cost) bbbsky.org

    • Earnings gain: Assuming a base income of $30,000, a 15% lift equals $4,500/year in added earnings.

    • Time to recoup cost: $2,500 / $4,500 ≈ 0.56 years (≈ 7 months).

    • Annual ROI: ($4,500 − $2,500) / $2,500 = 80% per year.

    • Cumulative 7-year ROI: Boosted lifetime earnings generate tax revenue that reimburses public investment in just 7 years, per Treasury analysis.

Why It Matters
This study validates mentorship as a cost-effective, scalable alternative to traditional remediation or prevention programs. For a modest annual investment, communities see gains in human capital, reduced social welfare dependence, and enriched workforce pipelines.


Program At-a-Glance

    • Demographics served: Youth aged 10–14 (early 1990s cohort), ~60% male, majority racial minorities, often from single-parent households.

    • Geography: National U.S., with sub-analyses in regions like Kentuckiana.

    • Activity type: Community-based one-on-one mentoring, ~1 year.

    • Metrics tracked: Longitudinal earnings, college attendance, absenteeism, suspensions, social service reliance, cost-benefit ratio.


Read Full Story